Buffalo Nickel: Understanding Its Value

Coin collecting is a thrilling and captivating hobby. For those of us who have been following the market for years, the Buffalo Nickel stands out as one of the most valuable and sought-after coins around. The iconic design and historical significance of this coin make it an essential piece in any serious collector’s portfolio. As an experienced numismatist, I’m here to provide you with all you need to know about understanding the value of these fascinating artifacts.

The Buffalo Nickel was issued by the United States Mint from 1913 to 1938. It features designs on both sides that are unique among U.S. currency: on one side there’s a profile portrait of a Native American chief named Iron Tail, while the other side has an image of Black Diamond, an American bison. This combination makes it instantly recognizable and highly desirable for collectors throughout the world.

In addition to its aesthetic appeal, different factors can affect how much each individual Buffalo Nickel is worth. Depending on their condition, mint mark (the letter stamped onto them indicating where they were made), date of issue, and whether or not they’ve been graded – all these elements contribute to their overall value. So if you’re looking to buy or sell one of these remarkable pieces, join me as we explore what sets them apart from other coins out there!

1. Design Of The Buffalo Nickel

The buffalo nickel, issued from 1913-1938, is a beloved coin among collectors. It’s design was inspired by the work of artist James Earle Fraser and its composition consists of 25% nickel and 75% copper. The obverse features an image of an American Indian while the reverse depicts an iconic American bison or buffalo. This classic design makes it easily recognizable and appealing to many people who admire this piece of US history.

Collectors are drawn to the detail in these coins as well as their rarity; only two versions were minted during production: with and without dates on them. In addition, there are several errors that can make certain variations more valuable than others such as doubled dies and repunched mint marks. Also some years have fewer surviving examples than others, making those particular specimens highly sought after.

Therefore, if you’re looking for a specific date or variety, your best bet may be searching through auction listings online or visiting dealers at coin shows where they offer graded coins for sale. With so much interest in the buffalo nickel, it has become one of America’s most cherished coins that continues to capture the heart of both novice and experienced collectors alike.

2. History Of The Buffalo Nickel

The Buffalo Nickel has been a staple in the United States since its production began in 1913. Not only is it aesthetically pleasing, but it also carries an immense amount of historical value and significance. To understand why this coin has become so important to Americans all over, let’s take a look at the history behind it.

Before there was the Buffalo Nickel, there were two other designs that preceded it: the Liberty Head nickel and the Indian Head penny. The Liberty Head nickel was minted from 1883 until 1912 while the Indian Head Penny was produced from 1859 until 1909. Both coins featured similar design elements like feathered headdresses or eagles, representing freedom and liberty for our country—icons which we still recognize today.

The Buffalo Nickel was introduced to replace these coins as a “representative American type”; in addition to its artistic beauty, its symbolism captured America’s spirit and values perfectly. It features James Earle Fraser’s iconic image of an American bison standing on top of a mound with inscriptions including “FIVE CENTS” and “E PLURIBUS UNUM” — Latin for ‘out of many, one’. This combination of images makes it clear that although individual states may be diverse, they are unified under one nation when joined together.

It’s no surprise then that after more than 100 years since its release, people are still drawn to collecting Buffalo Nickels; their unique story intertwined with powerful symbols make them valuable pieces of history that will remain cherished by generations to come.

3. Mintages Of The Buffalo Nickel

The buffalo nickel is one of the most iconic coins in American history. As a coin collecting expert, it’s clear to me that understanding its mintages can help anyone appreciate its value. In this digital age, having an artifact from 1913, such as the buffalo nickel feels like a time machine – taking you back into the days of Theodore Roosevelt and William Howard Taft.

Mintage figures for the Buffalo Nickel were higher than any other US 5 cent piece before or since. The first year of production saw over 27 million struck at all three mints. Most years after only had single digit millions produced making them more rare and valuable today.

Though mintages are important in determining rarity; condition also plays a large role when assessing value. Coins with original surfaces will bring significantly higher prices than those which have been cleaned or damaged by handling or environmental elements. Collectors should also note that certain dates command greater premiums due to their relative scarcity on the market place. All these factors add up to make the Buffalo Nickel quite desirable among collectors everywhere!

So if you’re looking for an eye-catching addition to your collection, look no further than the classic Buffalo Nickel – a coin sure to stir conversations about yesteryear and capture imaginations from generation to generation!

4. Types Of Buffalo Nickels

Ah, the Buffalo Nickel – an iconic piece of American coinage that has held a special place in the hearts and minds of collectors for generations. With its proud bison on one side, and stoic Native American chief on the other, it’s not hard to see why these coins are so beloved! But there is much more to understanding the value of this classic coin than just its beauty.

Let’s take a look at the different types of Buffalo Nickels out there. There were two primary varieties issued from 1913-1938: Type 1 with a mound below the buffalo, and Type 2 without. Both varieties come in three mint state grades – Good (G4), Fine (F12) and Uncirculated (MS60). Each type also comes in different denominations; 5 cent pieces, 3 cent pieces, Half Dimes and even gold $2 ½ Liberty Head coins! That’s quite a range to choose from when collecting Buffalo Nickels.

As you can see, whether you’re looking for something as small as a five cent piece or something big like a Liberty Head Gold Coin, there’s sure to be a Buffalo Nickel to match your interests and budget. So if you’ve been looking for an affordable entry point into the world of numismatics, then consider adding some beautiful Buffalo Nickels to your collection today!

5. Grading System For Buffalo Nickels

As a coin collecting expert, it is important to understand the grading system for buffalo nickels. Grading these coins can be crucial when determining their value and any potential collector should learn how to grade them properly.

First off, there are two major factors that determine the condition of a nickel: its surface preservation and strike quality. Surface preservation covers things like wear, scratches, tarnish and discoloration while strike quality focuses on the details in the design’s relief or if some parts appear flat-looking. The higher the score given by both features, the better the overall grade will be.

When discussing grades they range from Poor (P) to Uncirculated (MS). A P-1 is considered very worn down with no real detail left whereas an MS-65 is as good as it gets; nearly perfect in every way. In between these two ends of the spectrum lie Good (G), Very Good (VG), Fine (F), Very Fine (VF) and Extremely Fine (EF). To properly assign one of these designations requires knowledge about each specific issue’s characteristics so that more accurate decisions can be made.

To sum up, assessing the grade of a Buffalo Nickel involves examining its surface preservation and strike quality before assigning an appropriate numerical designation ranging from 1 to 65. As collectors become familiar with certain issues’ features they’ll eventually be able to accurately identify a coin’s grade without too much difficulty.

6. Key Dates In Buffalo Nickels

A buffalo nickel is a coin of immense value, both in terms of the history it represents and its worth as a collectible. As such, understanding the key dates associated with this iconic coin will help collectors understand its true worth. To that end, let’s look at some of the most important dates on these coins!

The first date to consider is 1913, when the Buffalo Nickel was introduced. This release marked the start of a new era for American coinage since it replaced Liberty Head nickels – which had been around since 1883 – with an entirely new design. The second key date is 1937, when production ceased after 24 years; making any examples from this year highly sought-after by collectors.

Finally, there are also certain rare varieties within the series that can be identified by their reverse dies (the back side of each coin). These include 1918/7-D overdate and 1938-D/S mintmark varieties; both extremely valuable pieces amongst serious numismatists. All in all, knowing about these key dates and rare varieties enables us to fully appreciate what makes buffalo nickels so special.

7. Variety Of Buffalo Nickels

Shifting gears, let’s take a look at the variety of buffalo nickels. As they say, variety is the spice of life – and this certainly applies to these coins! Not only were there different dates printed on them but also two distinct types: Type I (with no mound) and Type II (with a mound). In addition, each type had multiple mint marks ranging from Philadelphia, Denver, San Francisco, New Orleans and even Carson City. This means that depending on their condition or rarity, some are worth more than others.

The most sought-after version of the Buffalo nickel is known as the “Five Cent Piece” which was first issued in 1913. It has a unique design featuring an American Indian chief with crossed feathers behind his neck and the words “five cents” below it. Collectors treasure this coin for its historical significance as well as its eye-catching appearance. Other versions include the 1916/16 Double Die Reverse which has an error where both sides have been struck twice; this makes it highly collectible amongst numismatists.

Every collector should know about one other rare variation – The 1924 “S” Nickel. Only 8 specimens exist today making it one of the key date pieces among all US coins released during that era. While not many investors may be able to get their hands on this valuable piece due to its scarcity, understanding what kind of varieties are out there helps build your knowledge base when assessing value over time.

8. Factors That Affect Value Of Buffalo Nickels

Coin collecting can be a great hobby for any enthusiast, and one of the most popular coins to collect is the Buffalo Nickel. It’s no surprise that many collectors are keenly interested in understanding its value.
Did you know that over 240 million buffalo nickels have been minted since 1913? This makes them quite common and easy to find. But there are still some factors that affect their worth, so let’s take a deeper look at what influences the value of a Buffalo Nickel.
First off, condition plays an important role in determining the coin’s price tag. A nickel with minimal wear will typically bring a higher premium than one with heavy damage or scratches. Mintmarks also impact the overall value; specimens struck at San Francisco tend to have much greater market demand due to their rarity compared to other locations such as Philadelphia or Denver.
Finally, dates play a major factor when it comes to pricing – certain years may hold more significance than others depending on how many were produced during those years. For instance, 1912-S nickels boast only 866,000 mintage versus 1924-D which saw nearly 35 million pieces made! As an experienced Coin Collector myself, I’d recommend doing your research if you’re looking into investing in these iconic coins from yesteryear.

9. Collecting Buffalo Nickels

Collecting buffalo nickels is like a treasure hunt. You never know what you will find, and the rewards can be great! As a coin collecting expert, I’m here to help guide you through the process of tracking down these precious coins.

The first thing to remember when it comes to collecting buffalo nickels is that condition is key. Look for pieces that are in good shape – ones with minimal wear or damage – as this will affect their value significantly. Also, look out for any special editions such as proofs or varieties which could make your piece even more valuable.

When it comes time to purchase your buffalo nickel, don’t forget to do your research. Check online auction sites, dealerships and antique stores for the best prices on quality pieces. Finally, always keep an eye out at local flea markets and coin shows; you just might stumble across something amazing!

So get started on your hunting expedition today! With some patience and persistence, you’ll soon have a prized collection of buffalo nickels worth bragging about.

10. Investing In Buffalo Nickels

Investing in buffalo nickels is like stepping into a world of wealth and history. It requires an understanding of the rarity, condition, and mintage that make each coin valuable to collectors. With knowledge comes opportunity to collect some of the rarest coins out there.

As a coin collecting expert, I can tell you that investing in buffalo nickels isn’t just about having something pretty sitting on your shelf; it’s also about potential growth. Buffalo nickels rarely lose value over time and even if they do, it usually won’t be by much. This makes them a great long-term investment for those looking to increase their net worth without taking too many risks.

When done right, investment in buffalo nickels can be hugely rewarding. Rare coins tend to appreciate significantly faster than other investments such as stocks or bonds due to their limited supply. With wise decisions and an eye for quality, anyone can capitalize on this unique form of investing with remarkable results!

Frequently Asked Questions

How Much Is A Buffalo Nickel Worth Today?

Buffalo Nickels are one of the most sought-after coins in all of America. Its value is so priceless that it could make any coin collector’s heart race with excitement! Whether you’re a novice or an expert, these coins are sure to turn heads and cause envy from your fellow numismatists.

So how much is a Buffalo Nickel worth today? Well, let me tell ya – its worth has skyrocketed over recent years! A Buffalo Nickel can fetch anywhere from 20 dollars for common dates up to several thousand dollars for rarer specimens. It really depends on the condition and grade of the coin itself; if it’s graded as MS67 or higher, then you’ve hit the jackpot!

The bottom line is this: If you have any Buffalo Nickels tucked away gathering dust, now would be a great time to put them up for sale while they’re hot commodities. You never know just how much money they might bring in – it could be life changing! So why not take advantage of their surge in popularity and cash out before prices drop again?

What Is The Best Way To Store Buffalo Nickels?

Collecting Buffalo Nickels is a hobby that can quickly become an obsession. As the value of these coins continues to rise, it’s important for coin enthusiasts to find effective ways to store and protect their investments. In this article, I’ll discuss the best way to store your Buffalo Nickels so they remain in pristine condition for years to come.

The first step in storing any coin is ensuring its safe from dust, dirt, and moisture. To do this, you should invest in airtight holders with foam inserts or capsules made specifically for coins –– both of which will prevent oxidation over time. It’s also essential to keep your nickels out of direct sunlight as UV rays can cause discoloration on the surfaces of coins.

Finally, experts recommend keeping all coins stored away individually rather than grouped together due to potential scratches and other damage that could occur when two coins rub against each other. If possible, try using plastic folders or cases specially designed for holding small items like coins – they’ll help ensure the longevity and quality of your collection! All in all, taking extra precautions when storing your Buffalo Nickel collection is key if you want them to last a lifetime!

Is It Possible To Find Rare Buffalo Nickels In Circulation?

Coin collectors often wonder, is it possible to find rare buffalo nickels in circulation? The answer is yes! It’s not always an easy task but with a bit of knowledge and dedication, you can collect rare coins. Take the case of my friend, Gary. He was looking for a 1938-D Buffalo Nickel and he found one in his change at the grocery store. After careful examination, he discovered that it was indeed an original minted coin from 1937-1938 – and it was worth $200!

Searching for valuable coins like this requires patience and persistence. Keep your eyes open when going through rolls of coins or dealing with pocket change. Look up research on dates, locations, and mints to help you identify if any are particularly special pieces. If you’re lucky enough to spot something out of the ordinary (like Gary did), now’s the time to snap it up before someone else does.

Coin collecting takes commitment and consistency; however, there are plenty of rewards along the way. With some luck, perseverance and determination, you too might be able to add those hard-to-find Buffalo Nickels to your collection–and maybe even make a few bucks while doing so!

What Is The Difference Between A Type I And Type Ii Buffalo Nickel?

Coin collecting is an exciting hobby, and the buffalo nickel has been one of its most coveted pieces for decades. Aspiring collectors often wonder what distinguishes a type I from a type II buffalo nickel – so let’s take a closer look!

One way to tell them apart is by examining their reverse sides. The Type I design features two bison standing on either side of a mound of dirt; whereas the Type II displays only one larger bison in the center with no mound present. Another difference between these two types lies in their mint marks which can be found underneath the words ‘Five Cents’: Type I coins were made at three different US Mints (Philadelphia, Denver, and San Francisco) while Type II were all produced in Philadelphia.

So, if you’re looking to add a rare buffalo nickel to your collection, make sure you inspect both coin designs closely – it could mean the difference between having an ordinary piece or owning something truly special!

Are Buffalo Nickels Still Being Produced?

Coin collecting experts know that Buffalo Nickels are a highly sought after collectible item. But what many don’t realize is whether or not these coins are still being produced today. The answer is no; the last Buffalo Nickel was minted in 1938, meaning they haven’t been made for nearly eighty years!

Though it’s been decades since any new Buffalo Nickels have entered circulation, collectors can still find them around if they look hard enough. Many people will pass over them thinking they’re just regular nickels—but an expert eye will recognize their true value and rarity. These coins were only in circulation for less than twenty-five years before production ceased entirely, so even circulated examples tend to be worth more than most other common US coins.

The scarcity of original Buffalo Nickels makes them extremely valuable to coin enthusiasts. Since there won’t be any more of these coins coming out anytime soon, the ones currently available on the market are sure to continue increasing in price as time passes. It’s important for collectors to do research into both Type I and Type II varieties of the Buffalo Nickel to determine which one best suits their needs.


Coin collecting is a hobby that requires patience and commitment. And when it comes to understanding the value of Buffalo Nickels, this adage holds true: experience is worth its weight in gold. As an expert collector for many years now, I can tell you that these coins are highly sought after due to their rarity and historical significance.

Today, a Buffalo Nickel can be worth anywhere from $2 up to several hundred dollars depending on condition and variety. The best way to store them is in coin cases or albums specifically designed for nickel collecting. Finding rare Buffalo Nickels in circulation today can be difficult but not impossible if you know where to look – including antique shops and online auctions.

Finally, there are two distinct types of Buffalo Nickels: Type I (issued between 1913-1938) which featured the bison standing on a raised mound, and Type II (issued between 1938-2003) with the bison facing left towards the ground. While no new examples have been minted since 2003, they remain popular among collectors all over the world who continue to appreciate their beauty as well as their value!






Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *